Cards through a real invoice, as the default. The 3 percent fee reads like a cost until you price the alternatives: the check that bounced, the cash that never made it into the books, and the payment app account frozen in July. Take the others when it makes sense, but make card-by-link the path of least resistance.
The honest comparison
Cards. Cost you roughly 3 percent. Buy you: instant confirmation, automatic receipts, a card on file for the balance, payment plans, and a clean record if anything's ever disputed. Deposits get paid at 9pm from a couch, which is when parties get booked. This is the default for a reason.
Payment apps on personal accounts (Venmo, Zelle, Cash App). Feel free, and plenty of operators start here. The trade: no invoice, no contract linkage, business money mixed into a personal account, and terms of service that prohibit business use on personal tiers. The apps do close accounts for it, sometimes mid-season with money in flight. The business versions of these apps fix the account risk and start charging fees, at which point cards were the same price with better records.
Checks. Fine for schools, towns, and corporate clients whose accounts payable only speaks check. Build their longer timeline into the due date and don't mark the date confirmed until it clears. For consumer parties, checks mostly test your patience and your bank's mobile deposit.
Cash. Take it when offered, count it on site, write a receipt, and get it into the business account fast. Never build the collection process around it, because "he'll have cash at the event" is the first line of every unpaid-balance story.
The setup that works
- Every booking gets a real invoice with a card link. That's the rail.
- Deposit by card at booking, balance by card a week out, auto-reminded.
- Schools and towns get the check exception with a longer runway, stated up front.
- Cash and apps are accepted as exceptions you record immediately, not channels you manage.
One rail plus documented exceptions beats five channels you reconcile by memory on Monday.
The line to remember
You're not picking payment methods, you're picking bookkeeping. The method that documents itself is the cheap one, whatever the fee says.